Lumber spent November doing two contradictory things at once. The cash market kept falling, Madison’s framing lumber index at $443.65 per thousand board feet on 13 November, down 11.1 percent in a month, while futures staged a sharp rebound from roughly $500 on 12 November, the lowest since September 2024, to $537 by 20 November, up about 3 percent on the month. The bounce has two named causes: October housing starts surprised higher at a 1,309,000 annual pace, and West Fraser announced on 28 October it will indefinitely idle its Leola, Arkansas sawmill, pulling 225 million board feet of annual capacity out of a market whose builders are the gloomiest since 2012. Underneath both tapes sits the same variable as everything else this month, the December Fed decision, because NAHB’s own chief economist blames mortgage rates for the buyers who aren’t there.
| Grade / Item | Low | High | Unit |
|---|---|---|---|
| CME futures (20 Nov, OTC-derived) | 537 | 537 | USD/Mbf, +~3% m/m |
| Nov futures low (12 Nov) | 500 | 500 | USD/Mbf, lowest since Sep 2024 |
| 2026 futures high (July) | 664 | 664 | USD/Mbf |
| Canadian tariff burden | 34.75 | 34.75 | % total (24.75% duty + Sec 232) |
The tape, dated: cash falling, futures bouncing
| Series | Figure | As of |
|---|---|---|
| Madison’s framing lumber index (cash) | $443.65/Mbf, -1.2% w/w, -11.1% m/m | 13 Nov (NAHB, pub. 16 Nov) |
| CME lumber futures | ~$537, +0.75% day, +~3% month | 20 Nov (OTC/CFD-derived quote) |
| November futures low | ~$500 (lowest since Sep 2024); $507.50 settle was the 27 Oct 2026 low | 12 Nov / 27 Oct |
| 2026 futures high | ~$664 | July 2026 |
| October housing starts | 1,309,000 annual pace (from 1,191,000); permits 1,295,000 (down) | Census, Oct data |
| New home sales | 676,000 pace, -5.3% YoY; single-family starts -4% YTD | Sept 2026 |
| Canadian duty burden | 24.75% combined duty + Section 232 = 34.75% total | cut in Oct 2026 |
| Capacity cut | West Fraser Leola, AR idled: -225 MMbf/yr | announced 28 Oct |
Cash index via NAHB/Madison’s (16 Nov publication); futures path via Barchart/Yahoo Finance columns (19 Oct) and Wood Central (late Oct); 20 Nov quote is an OTC/CFD-derived price, not an official exchange settlement, and the source page itself showed $537.00 and $536.01 for the same date – we treat it as approximate. Checked 22 November 2026.
Two tapes, one market: why cash and futures disagree
The $93 gap between Madison’s $443.65 cash print and the $537 futures quote is the market arguing with itself about the winter. Cash reflects what mills can actually charge builders this week, and with NAHB confidence at its weakest since 2012 and more builders cutting prices than at any point this decade, that number has fallen 11 percent in a month. Futures price the spring: traders saw the October starts surprise, saw West Fraser’s capacity exit, and bid the forward market up off the $500 floor even as spot wood kept cheapening. One of the two tapes is wrong about 2027, and the honest answer is that the futures market has been the worse forecaster lately, down 12.6 percent in Q3 alone after July’s $664 high. Barchart’s Andrew Hecht, writing before the bounce, expected a test of $500 over the winter with support at $495 and $455.50; the bounce doesn’t refute the seasonality, it just moves the entry point. For perspective on how far this market has traveled: the old random-length contract touched $1,711 in May 2021 and $352.50 at the January 2023 low, so a $443-to-$537 argument is a quarrel inside a band that recent history treats as normal.
The tariff math nobody sees on a receipt
Commerce cut the combined duty on most Canadian producers to 24.75 percent in October, but the Section 232 tariff stacks on top for a total burden of 34.75 percent, and the arithmetic reaches every buyer through framing: NAHB counts 15,000 board feet in a standard single-family home, and 94 percent of new homes are wood-framed. At current cash prices that is roughly $6,650 of framing lumber per house before the tariff wedge on the Canadian share, which is why the duty regime functions as a floor under a falling market, the same role LNG exports play in our natural gas coverage: a structural demand-side or policy-side force that keeps a glut from clearing at its natural price. West Fraser’s Leola idling is the supply side answering, 225 million board feet a year withdrawn, and CEO Sean McLaren’s stated expectation of no near-term demand improvement tells you the capacity isn’t coming back for a data point or two. Lumber-linked equities confirm the mood: the WOOD and CUT ETFs both fell 5-6 percent between mid-September and mid-October, and Weyerhaeuser lost 9.5 percent to trade near its May lows, equity investors siding with the cash tape rather than the futures bounce.
Rates are the demand curve here too
NAHB chief economist Robert Dietz’s diagnosis, demand persists but higher mortgage rates keep buyers sidelined, makes lumber the fourth market this month whose price hinges on the December Fed decision, joining the gold, mortgage and used-car tapes in our mortgage rate coverage. The transmission is mechanical: every quarter-point on a 30-year mortgage prices out a tranche of first-time buyers, starts follow sales with a lag, and framing lumber demand follows starts with almost none. October’s starts jump to 1,309,000 is the bulls’ exhibit, but permits fell to 1,295,000 in the same report, and permits lead starts; the market bought the backward-looking number and discounted the forward-looking one, which is the kind of selective reading that tends to get corrected. For buyers of big rate-sensitive purchases, the pattern rhymes with our used car analysis: the cheap end moves first and hardest in both directions.
Our analysis
The cash-futures split is a weather-and-rates bet, not a disagreement about today. Spot lumber at $443.65 is what a 2012-grade builder mood buys you; futures at $537 are a wager that capacity cuts and a Fed cut arrive before spring framing season. The $93 basis is the price of that hope, and it is wide by historical standards.
Policy, not demand, is the floor. A 34.75 percent total tariff burden on Canadian wood plus voluntary mill idlings put a structural floor under a market that pure demand, sales down 5.3 percent, confidence at 14-year lows, would price materially lower; remove either prop and Hecht’s $455 support is in play.
Practical advice
- Building or renovating: cash lumber is 11% cheaper than a month ago and near the year’s lows; lock material quotes now rather than after a Fed cut reprices the forward market.
- Contractors: the futures bounce has not reached cash; quote jobs off Madison’s index, not off the CME headline.
- Prospective homebuyers: framing is ~15,000 board feet of your future house; a $100/Mbf move is roughly $1,500 of structure cost, small next to the rate math in our mortgage coverage.
- Watch permits, not starts: 1,295,000 and falling is the forward signal; the starts jump is last quarter’s decisions.
- DIY-scale buyers: retail lumber prices lag the cash index by weeks; the November cash drop should reach big-box shelves into December.
FAQs
What are lumber prices right now? Cash framing lumber averaged $443.65/Mbf on 13 November (Madison’s, -11.1% m/m); futures rebounded from ~$500 on 12 November to ~$537 by 20 November.
Why did futures bounce while cash fell? October starts surprised at 1,309,000 and West Fraser idled 225 MMbf/yr of capacity; futures priced the spring, cash priced this week’s thin order files.
What do Canadian tariffs add? A 24.75% combined duty plus the Section 232 tariff, 34.75% total on most Canadian producers, even after October’s duty cut.
Will lumber get cheaper this winter? Barchart’s Hecht expected a $500 test with support at $495 and $455.50; winter seasonality cuts demand, but mill idlings and tariffs argue against a collapse.
How much lumber is in a house? About 15,000 board feet of framing in a standard single-family home, and 94% of new US homes are wood-framed (NAHB).
What decides 2027 prices? The December Fed decision via mortgage rates, then permits; both the bull and bear case run through housing demand, not sawmill economics.
See our mortgage rate analysis, our used car price tracker, our natural gas tracker, and how we research prices.
Published 22 November 2026. Sources: NAHB framing lumber prices (Madison’s index, 16 Nov), Wood Central on the 2026 futures low and West Fraser idling, Andrew Hecht via Yahoo Finance/Barchart (19 Oct), Trading Economics lumber page (20 Nov quote; OTC/CFD-derived), checked 22 November 2026. Where sources disagreed on the same date, we said so above.


