The average US household will spend between $640 and $2,115 heating the same winter, and which end of that 3.3x spread you land on depends almost entirely on the pipe into your house: EIA’s Winter Fuels Outlook puts natural-gas homes at $640 for November-March, down 9 percent, electric heat at $1,196 (+4%), propane at $1,246 (-3%), and heating oil at $2,115, up 21 percent on a forecast $5.26 a gallon, itself up 34 percent. The oil number is the year’s fuel shock landing on the 3 percent of households, concentrated in the Northeast, least able to switch, while the fuel most homes burn gets cheaper. Winter 2026-27 is a lottery drawn by infrastructure.
| Grade / Item | Low | High | Unit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Natural gas (46% of homes) | 640 | 640 | USD, -9% |
| Electricity | 1,196 | 1,196 | USD, +4% |
| Propane | 1,246 | 1,246 | USD, -3% |
| Heating oil (\$5.26/gal, +34%) | 2,115 | 2,115 | USD, +21% |
The EIA forecast, fuel by fuel
| Fuel (share of homes) | Winter spending | vs last winter | Price forecast |
|---|---|---|---|
| Natural gas (46%) | $640 | -9% | $13.44/Mcf (-9%) |
| Electricity (~40%+) | $1,196 | +4% | 18.23¢/kWh (+3%), 6,562 kWh (+1%) |
| Propane (~10%) | $1,246 | -3% | $2.52/gal (-2%), 494 gal |
| Heating oil (~3%) | $2,115 | +21% | $5.26/gal (+34%), 402 gal (-9%) |
EIA Short-Term Energy Outlook, Winter Fuels perspective (October 2026 edition), November-March totals, nominal dollars; household shares per the 2024 American Community Survey as cited by EIA. Checked 21 November 2026.
The heating-oil shock, and who absorbs it
A 34 percent price jump to $5.26 a gallon is the same event our Thanksgiving travel analysis found at the gas pump: the year’s Middle East supply shock, still working through distillates, where heating oil competes with diesel for the same barrel. The households paying it are the ones the energy transition left on the oldest infrastructure, oil-heated homes clustered in New England and the mid-Atlantic, and even EIA’s own math shows them cutting consumption 9 percent, conservation and warm-weather luck, while their bills rise 21 anyway. The distributional point is the story: the fuel burned by 46 percent of homes fell 9 percent, the fuel burned by 3 percent rose 34, and a national “average heating bill” headline conceals that the pain is a regional, infrastructural minority’s, the same concentration pattern as every shock we track, from tariff aisles to egg flocks.
Weather is doing opposite things by region
EIA’s base case holds national heating-degree-days flat at 3,155, but the regional swings underneath are the real forecast: the Northeast is expected 12 percent warmer than last winter (4,331 HDDs), cushioning the oil shock for exactly the region that needed it, while the West runs 25 percent colder (2,781 HDDs), which is why Western natural-gas spending bucks the national trend at +7 percent and Western electric bills lead at +9. The agency brackets everything with 10-percent-colder and 10-percent-warmer side cases and flags a strong El Niño as the wildcard, so the honest reading of any winter-bill forecast is a range: a 10 percent cold surprise moves a $2,115 oil bill by roughly another $200 and a $640 gas bill by about $60, our arithmetic on EIA’s sensitivity design. Weather risk, like the price shock, lands hardest where the per-unit price is highest.
The electric line nobody budgets: heat pumps meet their first real test
n
The quietest number in the table may age the loudest: electricity, now the primary heat for roughly four in ten homes and growing with every heat-pump conversion, rises 4 percent nationally and 9 in the newly cold West, on rates (18.23 cents forecast) that have climbed each year of the data-center buildout. The heat-pump migration moves households off the delivered-fuel lottery and onto the grid’s pricing, which this winter is the right side of the trade against oil and the wrong side against gas, and the West’s 25-percent-colder forecast is the first broad cold-weather test for a generation of conversions sized in milder years. Households that switched should watch January bills for strip-heat hours, the costly backup mode cold snaps trigger, because the gap between a heat pump’s rated efficiency and its cold-snap reality is measured in exactly the kilowatt-hours the +9 percent West will bill for. The fuel lottery, in other words, is being slowly replaced by a single electric queue, and this is the first winter the queue’s pricing gets a cold-weather audit at scale.
The regional bill table
| Region | Natural gas | Electricity | Propane |
|---|---|---|---|
| Northeast | $879 (-14%) | $1,637 (-3%) | $1,687 (-15%), $3.28/gal |
| Midwest | $613 (-10%) | $1,380 (+3%) | $1,305 (-4%), $2.04/gal |
| South | $511 (-15%) | $1,079 (+3%) | $1,164 (0%), $3.19/gal |
| West | $590 (+7%) | $1,151 (+9%) | — |
EIA regional November-March forecasts. The propane spread is its own lesson: $2.04 in the pipeline-rich Midwest against $3.28 in the Northeast, a 61 percent premium for the same gallon, priced by logistics.
What a household can actually do with this
The forecast’s practical content is timing and triage. Oil and propane households buy their winter in discrete deliveries, so the +34 percent oil tape argues for price-shopping dealers now, locking what can be locked, and asking about budget plans and cap programs before January, while propane’s -2 percent says this is a normal year to fill early and skip the peak-week top-off premium. Gas and electric households ride utility tariffs that move slowly; their lever is consumption, and the $1,196 electric average is where heat-pump settings, strip-heat lockouts and the maintenance basics in our HVAC cost guide pay in kilowatt-hours. Assistance exists for the hardest-hit corner: LIHEAP applications open through state agencies each fall, and oil-state programs scale with exactly the price EIA just forecast up 34 percent. The one universal: the thermostat’s each-degree rule survives every fuel, and in a $5.26-a-gallon oil winter it is worth real money.
Our analysis
The same warmth costs $640 or $2,115 this winter, and the difference is plumbing. The 3.3x fuel spread, wider than any regional or weather effect in the forecast, is the single most consequential number in it; national averages hide that this winter is mild for the gas majority and a genuine shock for the oil minority.
The distillate shock is the gasoline story’s second act. Heating oil +34 percent is the Iran-conflict residue reaching the furnace, concentrated on 3 percent of households in one region, partially and luckily offset by a 12-percent-warmer Northeast forecast that El Niño could still revise in either direction.
Practical advice
- Oil heat: shop dealers and lock or cap prices now; the forecast curve is against waiting, and January deliveries price the panic.
- Propane: a flat-price year rewards the early fill; the Midwest-Northeast spread says your state, not the season, sets your rate.
- Electric heat: the +9 percent West forecast makes this the winter to audit heat-pump and strip-heat behavior.
- Gas households: enjoy the -9 percent, and bank it against the electric and delivered-fuel bills elsewhere in the budget.
- Every fuel: EIA’s ±10 percent weather cases are the honest error bars; budget the cold case, celebrate the warm one.
FAQs
What will heating cost this winter (2026-27)? EIA’s November-March averages: $640 natural gas (-9%), $1,196 electricity (+4%), $1,246 propane (-3%), $2,115 heating oil (+21%).
Why is heating oil up so much? A forecast $5.26/gal, +34 percent, as the year’s Middle East supply shock works through distillates; consumption falls 9 percent and bills still rise 21.
Who pays the most? Oil-heated homes, about 3 percent of the country and concentrated in the Northeast; the gas-heated 46 percent see bills fall.
How much does weather change this? EIA’s side cases run 10 percent colder or warmer; that is roughly ±$200 on an oil bill and ±$60 on a gas bill, with a strong El Niño flagged as the wildcard.
Why does propane cost so much more in the Northeast? $3.28 against the Midwest’s $2.04 for the same gallon, a 61 percent logistics premium set by pipeline and terminal geography.
Is help available? LIHEAP and state fuel-assistance programs open each fall and scale with exactly these prices; oil-state households should apply before the January delivery, not after.
See our Thanksgiving travel cost analysis, our Trane HVAC cost guide, our tariff-era grocery guide, and our mortgage rate tracker and our electricity price tracker and our natural gas tracker and how we research prices.
Published 21 November 2026. Source: EIA Short-Term Energy Outlook, Winter Fuels perspective (October 2026), checked 21 November 2026. Figures are forecasts in nominal dollars; the ± arithmetic on weather cases is ours from EIA’s stated sensitivities.


